02

Narrative

What is being said? What is being assumed?

6 observations

Mainstream media on inflation

Observation

Core inflation remains persistent in key categories. Governments continue to increase spending. Money supply is still growing.

Narrative

Inflation is falling and being brought under control.

Alternative View

Inflation may be structurally higher due to energy transition, demographics and debt levels.

Unknowns

What is the real velocity of money? How do off-balance sheet liabilities evolve? What happens if rates stay higher for longer?

The de-dollarization story

Observation

Central bank gold purchases and bilateral non-dollar settlements have increased. The dollar's share of global reserves and trade invoicing has declined slowly and remains dominant.

Narrative

The dollar's collapse as reserve currency is imminent.

Alternative View

Diversification at the margin is observable; replacement is not. The story may be both directionally real and dramatically overstated.

Unknowns

What settlement share would indicate a structural break? Which alternatives can absorb reserve-scale flows? Over what timescale do reserve transitions historically occur?

The return-to-office push

Observation

Large employers cite collaboration and culture when mandating office returns. Several of the same employers hold long commercial real estate obligations and have announced headcount reductions in the same period.

Narrative

Remote work failed. Offices are essential for productivity and culture.

Alternative View

Mandates may serve multiple goals at once: real estate utilisation, soft attrition, and managerial visibility, alongside genuine collaboration concerns.

Unknowns

What does within-firm productivity data actually show? How do attrition patterns differ post-mandate? Who benefits from each framing?

The housing shortage framing

Observation

Vacancy data, short-term rental counts and investor ownership shares vary widely between cities, yet the explanation offered is usually a single national 'shortage'.

Narrative

There are simply not enough homes. Build more and prices will fall.

Alternative View

Supply matters, but financialisation of housing, zoning incentives and where homes are built relative to jobs complicate a single-variable story.

Unknowns

How many units are held vacant, and why? What share of stock is owned by entities that never intend to occupy? Does new supply reach the price segments that are short?

The loneliness epidemic

Observation

Survey instruments measuring loneliness changed several times over the periods most cited. Some long-running measures show flat trends; the most alarming figures come from the newest instruments.

Narrative

Loneliness is at unprecedented crisis levels across society.

Alternative View

Something real may be shifting in social life, while the 'epidemic' framing may reflect measurement changes and media incentive as much as underlying change.

Unknowns

Which measures are comparable across decades? How does reported loneliness differ from time spent alone? Who funds the most-cited studies?

Screen time and teenagers

Observation

Effect sizes in large studies linking screen time to teen wellbeing are small and contested among researchers, while public discussion treats the link as settled and large.

Narrative

Smartphones broke a generation. The evidence is conclusive.

Alternative View

The harm may be real but concentrated: specific uses, specific ages, specific vulnerabilities, rather than 'screens' as a category.

Unknowns

Which uses of which platforms drive which outcomes? What explains cross-country differences in the trend? What would falsify the dominant claim?